IT Business

At which price point are we competitive enough?

Last week, after I changed up my presentation at MSPU to be a little more straight forward, I got to have several conversations with people who were extremely concerned not about the cloud, but their ability to compete with those that choose to go with it. Quote:

“With both Microsoft and Postini clearly advertising their pricing on the web site, I am finding it more and more difficult to offer solutions because clients are asking why they are paying so much more?”

This is where I give you my brilliant solution to the above problem.

I wish I had one. Sadly, I don’t.

This is something that has been beaten to death on Vladville since 2007 so I’ll sum up 3 years of posts in one paragraph: We’re seeing consumerization of business solutions which are making VAR/MSP margins tighter and technical solutions reduced to recommending which vendor to sign up with. As the technical competence becomes less and less relevant, the transition from a technology company to a marketing company becomes critical... for survival.

P.S. I’d like to take this opportunity to clear the air about the speculation my investments and about what I’m working on during my leave of absence and to which extent it’s going to help the above problem: It’s not. What I’m spending money on and building has everything to do with the paragraph above and absolutely nothing with the ability to price compete with a $5 Exchange mailbox or a $1 antispam solution. So please don’t buy the stories you’re hearing, if you’re concerned I’m one of the easiest people to reach – feel free to ask.

Reflection

Ok, I’ll admit that I chose the title to see if I can give my buddy Scott a heart attack. Don’t worry, this message is not about SPAM and it’s not funny.

The Leave

I’ve been somewhat disconnected from the core OWN businesses for about a week now which has given me some fresh air to contemplate exactly what our next move is and how committed I am to it. In order to tell you where we’re heading, allow me to tell you where we’ve come from.

My Take On Business

My parents are immigrants. The way immigrants make money is simple: “Hey, look at all that money those people gave to those people. How can I get some?” That in a nutshell is how OWN came to existence – I saw how much money people were willing to part with for Internet presence (so I started web hosting) and how when people are sufficiently annoyed by SPAM they will pay to get rid of it (so came ExchangeDefender) and how much it costs when they go down (LiveArchive) and how much people genuinely hate IT costs (so came our hosting/cloud revision in 2007 – for those of you that remember, I called it “The Lucy’s Sail” and outlined what you see today in a few articles on this very blog).

It’s a simple concept – find out where people are successful and find a way to fit in.

But… things have changed my friends.

Things like redundancy, in the words of my latest hire:

“it’s not a good word, it means that something is unneccessarily duplicated – but from reading your material it sounds like it’s a good thing?

Ouch! I think she’s 23. Which is the age of people starting businesses out of college.

Things like redundancy, clustering, failover, etc are a foreign language to them much like things like “legacy” and “Novell” were to me when I was starting my business. No, I was never impressed by someone who bragged about their Lotus 1-2-3 or how heavy their laptop was. Move aside geezer, take your stack of floppies over and let me show you this Internet thing.

That was 1997.

It’s been about 13 years since, I’ve built a multi-million dollar software company and a Ferrari Fund that will likely buy me a new model in every color for as long as I live and am stupid enough to spend money on cars. (P.S. Thank you for all your money!)

Life is good.

But solutions have to evolve.

Now, the complicated part:

Not all things evolve. Some die a horrific extinction.

Our current business – that of selling expensive technology solutions to people who appreciate the old way of doing business (relationships, global redundancy, failover, clustering, commercial licensing, etc) is coming to an end.

I will go on record in saying that I do not believe Microsoft Exchange will be the dominant messaging platform 10 years from now.

So, that leaves a bit of an awkward taste in your mouth when you say it.

It certainly leaves your employees a little uneasy.

But, at the end of the day it has to be said and something has to be done.

If there is one thing I believe…

You can’t ignore threats. Just because it threatens me, doesn’t mean I can ignore it because someone else will go for it. Inevitably, everyone else will go for it.

There is being right. And there is being broke. I’m trying to find the middle :)

The Honest Part

Part of me (and part of my company) believes that pursuing Microsoft and Google down the path of platform destruction is dangerous for two reasons: 1) With tight margins, value is destroyed and sacrificed for operational efficiency and 2) Who needs Own Web Now if they can get Own Web Now Lite for the third of the cost?

Both are valid concerns.

Allow me to address them as honestly as I can.

To make things cheap, you sacrifice value. However, the value being sacrificed is clearly something people are not interested in to begin with. The most successful companies on the Internet never publish a phone number. It doesn’t hurt them. So, is a human being that can help you a value or not? I’d argue that it doesn’t matter – if you don’t care about that, you will not pay for it – so it’s not a value after all. There is a long list of awesome and really incredible stuff we do at Own Web Now – but we work with Fortune 500, government, health care, financials and worldwide organizations. What we value will soon not be what the people demand.

There will be attrition if we devalue ourselves. Same response as the above: If people choose a solution with less “features” or “value” then our offering that means our offering didn’t actually have a “value” or “features” worth paying for. It’s a simple supply & demand argument.

What I’d really like to say is..

When competing against yourself, you’re trying to buy stuff you’d sell yourself.

When you look at a competitive offering, the natural fear is that it would cannibalize your revenues and destroy your company.

So there are two options: 1) Do nothing and eventually lose anyhow or 2) Do something and win less.

The math becomes very simple: Run things into the ground or make less money over longer term.

In one scenario, you end up with $0, in the other scenario you end up with something more than $0.

In the meantime, since you are competing with more than yourself only one of those outcomes is certain – the one in which your empire falls.

Bottom Line

I don’t know that Microsoft, Google, Amazon, etc are right.

I don’t know how committed I am to building something that’s not the “best thing, ever”

I do know that I’m not willing to surrender to any of them.

I also know that no matter how high the fear and uncertainty may be, I see my current attitude towards all this in the same way old people look at Facebook. The same way they can’t visualize the world without Quickbooks and the abomination that is a device that doesn’t back itself up every night is perhaps the kind of a tone my new hires get from hearing me.

And in all seriousness, I don’t want to grow up to be a CPA (not that one, I love her) of the technology world that can only offer a solution because of government regulation and clients sense of fear.

It’s time for something new.

Reverse Engineering Karl’s $249 package

Karl has made quite a bit of noise with his $249 / 5 user package and how he’s making money hand over fist. As usual, the devil is in the details but you can sign up for his Cloud Podcast over at www.smbbooks.com and at $5 a month it’s a steal – not to mention that it comes with 17 hours worth of service. Karl has blogged at length about it but this is really where it makes more sense to study than to just push the button.

Here it is in a nutshell:

5 Exchange Mailboxes w/ Antispam, Antiav..

250 GB File Storage

Destkop AV.

Vlad’s Pack:

The Exchange 2010 hosting package from Own Web Now - $10/user. This solution comes with SharePoint 2010. Mailbox, public folders, mail enabled contacts, all of SharePoint goodness.

ExchangeDefender - $0/user. This solution comes with SPAM filtering, antivirus, web filtering, business continuity (1 year worth of archiving powered by Exchange 2010) and so on.

Amazon S3 / Jungledisk - $5/user, $0.16/GB. Gives you a mapped drive on a Windows system tied directly to S3 service.

Note: You can get all the specific pricing and marketing plans, assistance from Own Web Now Corp. Because we don’t sell direct (only to IT Solution Providers) there is a short app but it’s free and just meant as a deterrent so we don’t end up with a law office as a client. :)

Let’s total this up, for 5 users and 250 GB of storage: $50 for Exchange, SharePoint, ExchangeDefender, LiveArchive, AV/Antispam, Web Filtering, Web File Sharing. $65 for 5 users of JungleDisk and 250 GB storage.

Total cost: $115. / mo

Total profit: $134. /mo

This price is far less than what people currently charge to manage an SBS server (for example) and the profit margin is higher. Besides, you don’t have to do a thing! Just crank out sales agreements and collect over a grand for it. When they ask for support, pile on more!

As usual, see www.smbbooks.com for more. ABP.

About Superpowers

Knowledge is crack, just try it and you’ll be hooked. And you’ll find out how clueless you were beforehand, or how clueless everyone around you is. That’s what’s so wonderful about technology, Internet, etc – it’s possible (given time, effort and actual willingness) to gain expertise at literally anything.

There are so many best practices on how to hire and groom good people that would make your head spin. Unfortunately, they are only good for hiring remedial labor when you’re seeking complacent people that treasure stability, no change or accountability (ie: drones). But most businesses do not grow (or in this climate, survive) with drones. And when you look for more gifted and talented people, the unfortunate circumstance is that smart people know how to manipulate data. Things like DiSC profiles for example, can be easily skewed if you know what the hiring manager is looking for.

To date, I have only found one thing that makes good people stand apart from the army of idiots looking for a paycheck: eagerness to learn.

Literally everyone who ever used to work for Own Web Now is no longer here because they refused or showed no interest in self improvement – from reading long form books that establish expertise down to reading Google. People that wait for direction and expect to be forced/sent to training are usually directed back to the job search.

It sounds harsh, but it’s all about superpowers..

If you’re skilled enough, you get a job.

Just because you got a job doesn’t necessarily mean you get to keep it.

And it certainly doesn’t mean you’ll ever get a raise or move up.

It’s amazing how many people don’t get the above fundamentals of work in the 21st century. Like I recently wrote in the Death of a Services Salesman, the opportunity to hide and slide is only there in the infancy when everyone is trying to figure out how to make it. Once the best practices are established, the only ones that survive are first movers (people who figured it out first and created a very large client base) and the cost leaders (people that can automate and price the solution down to the bare bones)

Where does that leave people in a job?

Well. I sat around with my marketing folks yesterday and we went through the agenda for the next month. Development of superpowers was key. What I mean by that is that things are only apparent and common sense when you study and learn about them.

They are only common sense because you’re aware of them.

The rest of the people have no idea that they are being manipulated, that everything they say and how they say it reveals what they are up to, that they are being coached and guided towards the (mutually) beneficial result.

In 2010 and beyond, I am only looking for people that are looking for more & better. I don’t care what your DiSC, history, education says – because that’s largely irrelevant. A year from now we’ll be doing very different stuff than what we do today and we need people that can get from here to there on their own.

Best blog post comment ever: “Nice Eulogy”

It took over a week to catch up with the comments regarding the “Death of a Services Salesman” blog series. I’m glad so many of you enjoyed it, I got more comments on this and more ad money than ever before. Now I can retire and live in a tent! :)

The commentary seemed split between oneliners that I read and long, extended rants that I deleted. Told you I would do that. If you have an opinion or insight that can fill more than a paragraph, honestly, you’re doing yourself and everyone else a disservice by not having a blog of your own.

“Nice Eulogy”

If you saw DoaSS as an eulogy, it probably was. Please turn the lights off on your way out.

On the other hand, we’ve seen this before. Technology (and solution providers) are naturally phased out by technological improvements. But that doesn’t mean that there is a mass extinction event on which everything as you knew it a second ago ceases to exist. Remember that Gmail has been out for 6 years and Microsoft signaled the current state of affairs at least 4 years ago (which leads me to believe that people that thought it was an eulogy didn’t actually read the blog posts but instead just reacted to their own fear of not being able to continue running business as usual)

Quite the contrary, the phase out period is extended – but only the first movers tend to survive. They get to the new market before the rest of the sheep flood it and completely render it impossible to differentiate and compete in.

The faster you accept that things are changing, the faster your company will grow. No, this blog is not meant as an abuse broadcast system (another comment) – it’s meant as a sounding board. I speak to hundreds sometimes thousands of people each week – and I use this blog to voice the insight I get from my interactions to see if I’m only getting a message from a small/vocal biased group or if this is an overall state of industry.

That’s how I know that if you’re sitting around formulating strategies over virtualizing servers in the cloud you’re stuck in 2006. Remember when good ol’ Vlad talked about a $99 SBS box and had thousands of them running? Yeah, good luck selling that today – you’ll find a handful of people with a lot of money and the number of people that consume IT like that is decreasing, not increasing. So by all means, try to run your consulting practice like you did in 2006 – few clients with thousands of dollars to burn on IT. High risk, slow deployments, expensive staff – and the few SMB bloggers that are still around will hopefully speak fondly of you and what a great job you did building the company’s first LAN.

The point of DoaSS is to make you move – quickly. If after reading it you don’t have a sense of urgency, go read it again.

DoaSS: Coping & Profiting

Over the last four posts I looked at the major factors contributing to the death of the IT solution providers in the SMB sector. To quickly review, we’ve seen a lot of people hang up the hat because:

  1. They were too focused on technology they were comfortable with 
  2. Their value proposition did not match their market (they pitched big expenses to small businesses)
  3. They could not cope with the competition from larger providers, global companies and former suppliers that passed them by
  4. They underestimated the length and severity of the downturn combined with the changing taste for technology

The truth is undeniable, we all know a lot of people who used to be in this business that are now doing something else. And when faced with the prospect of looking at our peers failure, we have a fair amount of grief to deal with. Elizabeth Kubler-Ross outlines the five stages of grief:

  • Denial – There is no IT downturn in IT, so many SMB solution providers are still thriving. Plus, how are Dell, HP and Cisco growing?
  • Anger – It’s all Apple, Microsoft, Google, Dell and Obama’s fault (that last one I threw in for my buddy Chris Rue)
  • Bargaining – If we redesign our business, and SWOT and change our marketing, surely we have a shot?
  • Depression – Whatever, we can’t compete against Google so we’ll just focus on being a small specialty provider.
  • Acceptance…

Acceptance

Lot’s of people will surely want to pick a fight over the many, many points I’ve made here. I encourage you to. Please write your own public blog post or write a comment on any of the four pages because I will not be addressing personal emails written on this subject – there are far too many people that read this blog that are dealing with this problem and we owe it to one another (in this industry) to have this discussion in the open while we’re still talking about the present (and future) not the past.

The IT Solution Provider industry (VARs, MSPs, etc) need to accept the fact that the good ol’ times of “investing in technology as a competitive advantage” are gone – everyone has technology now.

We need to accept that there is no such thing as “local presence” anymore and that global is the new local – bringing with it lower wages, more intense and more competent competition.

We need to accept that the days of the right solution being the only solution are gone – thanks to the many alternatives and substitutes the building blocks of a technology solution have permanently changed the taste and the demand.

Determination

If you’re capable of making it past the previous section, it’s time to make a decision. The simplest one is to say Screw you Vlad, you’re wrong. Or…

Opportunity: You could look at the clients that passed on your solution and ask them why? What did you pick? How come?

Sure, you could embrace the cloud but there are only going to be so many players left there. When it comes to competing with the likes of Microsoft and Google (which have huge cash cows sustaining their deep losses in their effort to work directly with the consumer) the odds are against you.

Yeah, you can charge people a markup for the cloud, but how does that make you competitive – everyone can do that. Maybe you can be an expert at moving people to the cloud and charging a service markup – yet again, you’re becoming an expert at something that everyone can do. And already does!  You’re just shifting your existing service to another platform (be it virtualization or cloud) and with it the same stuff that the clients don’t care about and you get no differentiation from.

Trust me: If some genius figured out the above paragraph, they’d be rolling in billions, not sitting in zip code 12345 pretending to be an expert.

What is going to make you sufficiently different from your competition when you’re using the same platform, same suppliers and at relatively similar cost structure?

This is something that I’ve spent the last 8 or so months trying to figure out. I think you’ve seen OWN (if you actually work closely with us, not the blog posts and public stuff) starting to go in that direction.

Supporting vs. Patronizing

I’m sure that many of you will see this as a very unsupportive message. But Vlad, if all of us are screwed, where does that leave the only OWN client – the partner? You go under too, right? Go back up and read about denial.

My job as the CEO of OWN is to help our partners grow. Not to sit idly by and pretend like there are no problems out there and patronize folks to their slow and inevitable death. Yes, I’m pretty sure that most of the service providers will be gone within 24 months – so my job is to figure out a way to push the ones that will be left around in the right direction and provide support systems for them to compete.

And that, dear friends, is what separates successful people from the failures. Ignoring problems doesn’t make them go away – embracing them and trying to find a solution is a trait that has and will sustain companies with the technical evolution, no matter where it takes us. The question is, can you spot it?

DoaSS #4: Thinking it’s the economy

In late 2009 through early 2010 we’re seeing an unprecedented death rate of technology businesses involved in SMB (VARs, MSPs, technology experts), traditionally reseller-friendly companies going direct and the rapidly changing set of rates (from netbooks to computer service to “app store” software) for technology. The five part series titled “Death of a Services Salesman” will explore these trends, the causes behind them and hopefully give some clarity to the many that are rightfully asking: Are the good times in technology services gone for good?

When did it start slowing down?

The demand for IT services in SMB actually slowed down before the release of SBS 2008. I remember conversations with my partners rather vividly because nearly everyone back then thought the temporary slowness was due to the coming releases of Windows 7 and Small Business Server 2008. If you go back even on Vladville or Karl’s blog you’ll see a number of posts talking about how SBS 2008 might be the last server you ever sell.

Yes, the hindsight is 20/20 but it clearly marked the end of big deals in SMB. Which brings me to the 4th reason why the SMB solution providers are dying: thinking that it’s the economy.

It’s not the economy…

It’s not the economy. Or more specifically:

Problem: It’s the economy you remember.

That economy is long gone. It ain’t coming back. Much like dialup Internet service providers aren’t posed for a comeback, or the days of AOL keywords, technology that gets obsoleted over time is not closely tied to the general economic swings.

Critical components of every economic system are supply and demand. And supply is affected by substitutes: items that buyers are willing to purchase as an alternative to your product/service that produces a similar benefit. Strap on your seat belt, we’re about to travel through time:

Kicking the Delorean up to 88mph..

Welcome back 1997. Your desktop cost $2,000. Your laptop cost $3,000 and weighted as much as a briefcase will in 2010. Sony introduces Vaio F505, a slim light weight laptop that costs $4,000 and with a 10” screen represents the future in which most computers will be sold with slim 10” screens.

You need to connect your business to the Internet. You’ve got a choice of a dialup connection with Exchange 5.5 doing ETRN, a dedicated ISDN (one channel or two) or a T1 or better starting in four figures a month.

It’s time to get rid of that Novell server and try this new Microsoft NT thing. Problem is, you need to hire a network engineer and those start at $40,000. Business is business, time to invest in the company and use the technology to get to the next step. So you hire that engineer, do some situps, do a 100 pushups a day in your office and one day you’re strong enough to lift a copy of Computer Shopper.

You need a server, a switch or a hub, a CSU/DSU, a tape backup system… Wait, what’s that? A company that can figure out all this mess for me and possibly save me thousands of dollars?

Back to the Delorean and to 2010:

Problem: The “value" that VARs used to deliver (that of technical expertise) is no longer deemed to be of premium value. Our rate sheets are from the days of $4,000 laptops, $2,000 desktops, $10,000 server deployments. Those times are over.

We no longer need a company to contract a purchase of Internet access complete with a CSU/DSU, router, switch, firewall. We can now go down to a Verizon or Sprint store and they’ll hand us Internet that can fit into our pocket and be shared with 5 other people.

You no longer need an MCSE to offer technology advice.

Newspapers are dying.

It’s a different age all together.

A single engineer can manage thousands of workstations from a remote office (or a remote country at a far lower rate) and the opportunities for a network engineer went from every company needs one to only Fortune 500 needs a few.

And much like the Skynet system in Terminator, the more perfect the automation system of controlling all these devices and networks gets, the less need there is for a human being to watch after every one of them. The machines are controlling the machines.

Best Practices Change Over Time

If you’re in break’n’fix, “trying to go to managed services” is an opportunity that has passed you by. As discussed in the previous post, the competition is fierce and it’s coming down to competition on price.

The services we used to rely on servers for have gone to the clouds. The workstation has been replaced by the laptop and the laptop has been watered down by the netbook. The future is on the touchscreen. The last person still serving an engineering firm that needs to have a local file server for really large CAD drawings will turn off the light.   

The best practice of where files sit, how they are backed up, who can access them and who controls who can access them has changed.

Problem: The mere fact that we’ve left the days of technological entropy and further adoption of technology no longer causes further spending and chaos is amazing. The age of highly compensated engineers has been replaced by the age of Geniuses working in retail stores advising you which of the 5 computer models is right for you. Unfortunately, for most people the difference between a professional service and a $10/hr Genius is indistinguishable.

…

While the temporary recovery in the economy and the technology refresh cycle may give some hope that the things are finally turning around, the reality is that the new economy with all its new technology, automation and alternatives has permanently changed the cost structure and the expectations small businesses have of their technology.

When you no longer need a technology department because you can get one in an Apple or Verizon store then you no longer need a CIO and you no longer need a VAR or an MSP. Most of the VARs and MSPs were established on building and managing networks for companies with under 100 employees. With that demand disappearing, so does the need for many technology companies and it’s the #4 reasons why IT solution providers in small business are disappearing.

…

Now, the beauty of business is that it doesn’t have a life limited by age. It has a life limited by imagination and opportunity. So the days of building and managing networks is not enough to sustain a growth or revenue levels – so what?

We’re not selling dialback ISDN plans in 2010, are we? Are we crying to have those days back? Heck no, the opportunity for developing solutions on top of high speed Internet is far greater than the markup we used to get on a single service solution.

The connectivity and automation have brought us a global opportunity, not just one limited by the amount of time we’re willing to spend in a car to reach a client. As have tastes – you no longer need a flight and a round of golf to make a deal.

While the world will always need a bicycle shop and a VCR repair man, the world moves forward for a reason – things get better! And with it, we have to as well – because there is a lot more money to be made and much more interesting problems to be solved.

Join me tomorrow for the final post in this series, exploring the further Death of a Services Salesman and what is coming out of it’s ashes.

DoaSS #3: Thinking local

In late 2009 through early 2010 we’re seeing an unprecedented death rate of technology businesses involved in SMB (VARs, MSPs, technology experts), traditionally reseller-friendly companies going direct and the rapidly changing set of rates (from netbooks to computer service to “app store” software) for technology. The five part series titled “Death of a Services Salesman” will explore these trends, the causes behind them and hopefully give some clarity to the many that are rightfully asking: Are the good times in technology services gone for good?

What’s “local” anymore?

Before I even state the extremely obvious challenge SMB IT solution providers face from all fronts, I’m going to share the answer nearly all the providers in this space have given me in 12 years in this industry when asked how they build their business: referrals. The word of mouth, do a good job and hope the client is happy enough to recommend you to someone else. Or even ask/incentivize them to do so. Or join a business referral network.

Problem: There is no such thing as “local” anymore. The competition for IT services is now global.

Talk about the blue ocean strategy backfiring: Where people hoped they would find unlimited opportunity of untapped markets, they found more competition from more aggressive predators. Every day I am greeted to a spam bucket full of Indian programmers by the pound and by the minute, call center outsourcing, temp labor and skilled workers waiting to work for the fraction of what anyone would expect in United States. But do you want to know what the #1 predator in the blue ocean is?

Problem: Our suppliers are now our direct competition.

Competing against suppliers

This is nothing new, we’ve always known that large box makers have been direct. Some (Dell) have had direct as a motto and principal value. They always wanted a direct relationship with the client.

What is new in this equation is that these companies now deliver services. It was easy to ignore them when all they did was ship equipment – but now the equipment is shipped with the maintenance service already purchased, from warranty to monitoring to offsite backups to antivirus. The whole purpose the VAR industry served – that of taking something raw and turning it into a functional business tool that can deal with the real world networks (appropriate software, antivirus, licensing, configuration) is now done by the manufacturers.

The whole “MSP Revolution” was short lived, with Dell’s acquisition of Silverback the same core value MSPs were offering now became a checkbox on Dell’s site. And they aren’t afraid to make a phone call or even hold an order back until they talk to you about managing the purchase you’re about to make.

Competing against larger providers

In the previous blog post I discussed the strength in numbers.

With the recent economic problems caused in part by implosion of the banking system, the word “trust” has almost been wiped out of the dictionary. With all the (possibly criminal) activity the banks have committed, there aren’t fewer people doing business with Bank of America – the “too large to fail” is somehow less of a concern than the thousands of small banks that are small enough and failing in large numbers. It’s not fair but it’s business and the purchasing criteria has changed.

At Own Web Now we do business with a lot of managed services providers that service multiple states – not just two or three but a dozen – and they are the ones that are growing fastest. It could be that they are just aggressive by nature – but it’s more likely that the marketing message of “we are larger and more resourceful than your local mom & pop IT shop” resonates with the business owners that are spending their money on technology because their ambitions are larger than just the walls of their office.

Competing against the cloud

I’ve written hundreds of blog posts about this point and it’s something I don’t have anything new to say. Every software powerhouse has or is working on a cloud strategy that goes direct. It is so powerful that many service providers are forced to hand over their clients for 6% commission of $5.

…

Some people live to compete. The rest die because they refuse to.

That’s at least my opinion. People that sat on the sidelines waiting for the “cloud” to materialize are now dying. Not because the cloud is taking their clients, but because their existing clients have downsized or closed doors and it takes time and effort to build a marketing and delivery system built around the cloud.

With nearly unlimited competition from suppliers and other providers, it’s harder to commit to larger marketing & sales efforts which inevitably allows the loss of client base to outpace new business.

The most amazing (to me) part of ignorance comes from the providers that have been around for a while, improved their marketing, their sales, their procurement and their reputation in the industry – but haven’t grown as a result of it. If you’ve improved everything but your bottom line that’s not success – that’s churning.

Thinking that local is a closed environment is the #3 reason IT solution providers are dying. I find many people face this problem with an immense sense of denial – even when confronted about their local competition most will say that they have less competition now than ever before (because they only view the people they can see – that are now bankrupt – as competition). The economy and the demand for services has changed. Sitting back and waiting for it to change back is an option, sure, but doesn’t it make more sense to just compete at a different level?

DoaSS #2: Thinking small

In late 2009 through early 2010 we’re seeing an unprecedented death rate of technology businesses involved in SMB (VARs, MSPs, technology experts), traditionally reseller-friendly companies going direct and the rapidly changing set of rates (from netbooks to computer service to “app store” software) for technology. The five part series titled “Death of a Services Salesman” will explore these trends, the causes behind them and hopefully give some clarity to the many that are rightfully asking: Are the good times in technology services gone for good?

Thinking small for small business..

Personally, this has been my biggest failure as a business owner. I did not recognize when OWN matured past my own ambitions and agenda and I didn’t get aggressive enough quickly enough. This is an issue I find many of the people in the SMB solution space face and it’s the #2 reason contributing to the death spiral we’re seeing out there among solution providers:

Problem: We’re a small business too. Just like you. So we know what it’s like and are better positioned to help you!

What may seem like a very warm familiarity pitch turned out to be fatal during the downturn in which many entrepreneurs faced their own mortality. Now the taste has changed. Now people want larger brands. Established companies on a solid ground. Having been burned by everything from Circuit City to local branches closing, people want a brand!

One of my friends and most successful MSPs out there (ARRC) has a HaaS division called CharTec through which they make it possible for managed services providers to offer computer and network systems (everything from a workstation to a phone system) for a low monthly fee as a subscription service. And guess what, they sell inferior (by spec) HP workstations over OEM ones for more because some partners have a challenge selling “white boxes” – now mind you that these aren’t white boxes at all! – but the sentiment has changed.

Problem: When people are not just willing but persisting in choosing even an inferior solution over the one you recommend because they are more inclined to trust the big brand than you, your days as a solution provider are numbered.

We build and manage SBS and SBS networks..

This has been the pledge of allegiance for small business solution providers for the past decade. When Microsoft released EBS (mid-market version of SBS) there was a lot of rejoicing about how this product will revolutionize the midmarket and make technology there so much easier to manage and administer.

Then Microsoft killed EBS. And they recommended replacing it with Microsoft Online Services (hosted Exchange/SharePoint). Double ouch!

Problem: What Microsoft knows, and the rest of it’s providers seem to have only tepid willingness to accept, is that people are no longer see value of owning their own local area network.

But take your average solution provider than half their product sheet is filled with high margin junk to build a network that can serve thousands and thousands of people with the uplink speed that wouldn’t even provide for a good Xbox game. And when that fails people turn to their iPhone/Android and wonder – which one was a good investment? Which one is working for me now?

The tastes have changed.

The needs have changed.

Back in the 90’s we needed a local area network because there was no high speed network in our pocket. We needed a server because we couldn’t keep a ton of data on our workstation because there was no efficient way to back it up. We needed Active Directory because there was no way to control and restrict access to applications and documents if you could browse to them.

Now all of that can be done with a cell phone and a free web app. If you want to be fancy, you can spend a few bucks a month and get one with “enterprise” features.

Fatality Check: My MCSE exams had roughly a quarter of it’s questions covering permissions, inheritance, which options “deny” permission would override – and in 2010 thinking that you needed an engineering certification to grant or deny access to a document would get you laughed out of a job interview.

Problem: If people aren’t willing to pay to build a network, what makes you think they will be willing to pay to have one professionally managed when even Microsoft has given up on it?

…

When it comes to small business solutions, service providers tend to represent small (company) but pitch big (solution)! The client has an option of small, local and expensive over big, global and affordable.

This is the second reason we’re seeing a rapid decline in opportunities for small business solution providers. You don’t have to look far to see who wins out in that equation over the long term – Walmart, Home Depot, McDonalds, etc. Now, as soon as I figure out how to make a Versce or Ferrari brand out of technology solution providers I’ll let you know, in the meantime join me later this week for the other two reasons small business solution providers need to think very differently about what kind of business they need to be building.

DoaSS: #1: Thinking about technology

In late 2009 through early 2010 we’re seeing an unprecedented death rate of technology businesses involved in SMB (VARs, MSPs, technology experts), traditionally reseller-friendly companies going direct and the rapidly changing set of rates (from netbooks to computer service to “app store” software) for technology. The five part series titled “Death of a Services Salesman” will explore these trends, the causes behind them and hopefully give some clarity to the many that are rightfully asking: Are the good times in technology services gone for good?

We’re all about technology...

When you look at your traditional SMB technology provider, we’re for the most part all about technology. It’s our passion. It’s our business model. It’s what we live to do.

The implementation varies a bit from resellers to managed services providers but for the most part you’re not going to find former Fortune 500 CEO’s behind SMB tech firms. You’ll find a geek.

If you’re lucky, you’ll find a geek with an MBA.

We’re going to be your trusted advisor…

The focus of the sales model in SMB has always been on trust. You can trust us. You can see us. You can count on our advice because if the advice we sell you fails, we’ll fail.

So much of the sales process in SMB is built on trust that most conference content these days is focused on having panels (comprised of trusted advisors) discussing a way to compete with multi-billion dollar corporations that don’t even have a support phone number (or at best one that speaks fluent English). It’s fantastic conference fodder because it builds on the fear many face and it’s successful because it keeps up the myth that the threat is external (“Those guys are after our clients!!!”) and doesn’t confront the attendees with the actual, real problem.

…

The real problem: The future of technology use in business is all about business, not at all about technology.

Doubt that? Go to random 5 web sites of SMB technology providers (Google “_my city_ managed services”) and look at their About Us pages. You’ll find the pages predicated on the important factors that the business owner(s) found when they were employed by large companies and all they did was IT. We bring enterprise to small business. We give you the power of technology that big companies have at small business rates. Count our acronyms and certifications, we’re so well connected with the technology vendors we forgot who we’re selling to! Ok, that last one is probably not going to be spelled out quite the same but you will find a lot of irrelevant junk on the web site that will never lead a business owner to make a purchase.

There is a clear mismatch of a business agenda, business model (what are we selling to whom and how) and business offerings (what would you say you do for a living?)

…

Most people in this industry will also mount a very long list of arguments for why that is the right way to go about business: It’s technology, stupid! The problem with technology as a business is that the technology has changed so rapidly that most technology business owners cannot even cope with what the future looks like: What do you mean there is no server, where are files going to sit? Seriously, who will ever think of doing all their business on a shrunken keyboard matched with a 10” laptop screen? Communicate with people on a phone? With no keyboard? Get out of here!

Technology business owners focus on features and complete solutions to problems. Business owners focus on business and view technology as an expensive obstacle (pain) they deal with in order to get things done.

Many of my colleagues will fight with me over the above statement, but the sad truth is that their business would not event exist if businesses didn’t see technology as a pain worth paying to fix. Yes, there are some clients that see technology as a competitive advantage bust most are only willing to pay for problems to go away. Problems with the traditional technology deployments.

This has been the fundamental component of the rise of managed services providers. Now, it’s the leading factor contributing to their death:

Anything that can be measured can be managed.

Anything that can be managed, could be automated.

Everything that could be automated will be done by the lowest bidder, which realizes profits at a large scale which can only be accomplished when you focus on business not technology. Ouch!

Seriously. Look at Gmail. It’s got privacy issues. It’s got reliability issues. It’s virtually supportless and unaccountable – you can find your account nuked and nobody will even offer an explanation. In comparison to features found in Outlook, it looks like something we would have tolerated last century. Yet somehow, it’s the most popular SMB thing out there? Really? The fundamental competitive difference with Gmail (and it’s corporate cousin) is that it doesn’t care about what the geeks care about – it only worries about the user and the ability to send mail.

Talk about a solution that gets out of the users way and let’s them focus on business, huh?

Many in the SMB VAR/MSP space like to throw around the phrase “Let us worry about technology so you can focus on your business“ but one look at their solution stack makes it clear that they are only interested in putting more technology in front of the user, not less.

This is one of the four reasons technology solution providers are dying, rapidly. Unfortunately, this fact is not lost on the suppliers, vendors and other stake holders which are starting to pull their support and instead compete directly for the business.