Microsoft

Breaking down the Microsoft vs. Linux Patent Scare

(not a rant, hey there is first time for everything)

By now you’ve surely seen at least a dozen articles on how, depending on the source, Microsoft is ready to eliminate Linux from existence or collect royalties or sue “them” into oblivion. It’s a juicy topic because it’s about a lot of money, emotion, business with a great protagonist and so on. Everyone from Scoble down to the guy with a rock standing in front of a copyright billboard has chimed in. What’s it really about and why will it never happen?

It’s about Microsoft trying to put the Interop picture together for Longhorn.

Because nobody likes Microsoft already, and suing will only make it worse while admitting failure.

Point 1: It’s not about Linux.

Many bloggers will pull stories and anecdotes about how this is about a huge company that is seemingly falling apart (while making 14 billion dollars a quarter) exerting it’s power to eliminate competition. They then transition to the conspiracy theories that SCO lawsuits were funded by Microsoft. Then they support that by a dozen or so articles in which Microsoft lost the patent lawsuit and had to part with a mountain of cash. And, for the cherry on top, they sprinkle something about Microsoft stealing from Apple for 25 years, how any offending code would be rewritten/removed within hours, etc. But in a nutshell, the take of nearly every article is about an evil Microsoft trying to kill off the little Linux.

Meanwhile at the ranch Microsoft is working at perhaps the most significant software release in it’s history, Longhorn Server, which will set it miles apart from any other server suite available just like it’s done with it’s Office suite. And if you see where Microsoft actually makes money you realize that selling Microsoft’s next server into the enterprise involves having a decent interop story for the customer. Whether Microsoft likes it or not, the business reality is that more and more ISV’s are writing software and delivering it on Linux servers – so for Longhorn to be a sell it has to be able to prove it can play nicely. Thats all there is to all this: Microsoft is trying to build up it’s glossy orange flyer with Linux distribution vendors who have signed interoperability agreements so Microsoft can go to the customer and say “Look, you run Redhat, Novell, Ubuntu and Debian and we have interop agreements with those folks to make sure the application you just purchased will be compatible with the middleware you have running on Windows Server” – and how do you coerce the distribution vendors into siding with you and working on Interop? By sprinkling a little patent doubt in the air which you (Microsoft) know full well you won’t be pursuing.

 

Point 2: Enough people already hate Microsoft

There are 800 lawyers at Microsoft, likely 780 of them are there to deal with continuous lawsuits stemming from inappropriate behavior that happened ten years ago. But read the blogs and you’re left with the impression that those 800 lawyers are just there to do recruiting to get more lawyers to sue FOSS out of existence.

It’s not difficult to find people that hate Microsoft, be it a developer a customer or partner. When you’re big you’re bound to screw people. Heck, even a one man shop has managed to make enemies for itself. Just the nature of business.

So let me clue you in to a little thing about Microsoft that I’ve learned about their culture through working with them for the past 10 years or so. Microsoft guys, be it in sales, development, even executive levels truly believe, beyond a shadow of doubt, that they are the best. Absolutely, without question, Microsoft BOB in one hand and Windows ME in the other, 640K ought to be enough for everyone – the best. Whether they are right or not, Microsoft, by culture, believes they are the best, with the best value, best technology. How? Through innovation.

Going into extended patent lawsuits would make it pretty clear to its shareholders and employees that Microsoft is no longer a business built on innovation and expertise, but one that barely survives on the very thing they have been widely accused for years – FUD. Which is why you’ll never see the lawsuits. It would be ridiculously expensive and highly demotivating for the company culture and what Microsoft stands for.

Microsoft doing a patent suit over innovation is similar in experience to the blind test of which soda you prefer. If you don’t win do you turn around and say “Wow, I’ve been a jackass for 20 years, thank you, thank you for pointing out what I’d like drinking better” or do you walk away in resentment that you picked incorrectly?

Same for the Microsoft customers. Their customers already dislike the business practices that Microsoft has. They outright hate the licensing. Developers and partners aren’t far behind. And we’re ALL buying software and hardware from other companies. So is Microsoft going to pour gasoline on that fire by telling us, to our face, that we’re thieves as we have already purchased solutions based on non-Microsoft products? Or will they just try to build a better story about how this new thing they have coming will play nicely with that third party stuff we already bought?

Personal note:

As you’ve seen on this blog, I talk a fair amount of smack against Microsoft. Yes, they deserve it. I also run more Microsoft software than any sane person ought to be allowed to. I’ve been awarded a Microsoft MVP award for two years in a row. I send large checks to Microsoft, on monthly basis, all while bitching about how Microsoft is putting me in the early grave with lack of patch QC. I write about problems and solutions for Microsoft software, all while leading ITPRO groups focusing on Microsoft software. I develop software for the Microsoft platform. And on daily basis I am asked if I love or hate Microsoft, if I’m pro or con Microsoft, if, if if. Everyone wants a fanboy.

The key thing to understand here is that when it comes to business there are many shades of grey, many circumstances, many compromises that have to be made as you go on. Thats what makes people successful, realizing that there are tradeoffs to every position. The alternative, as you’ve seen in the blog posts on this subject, is to take black vs. white approach to it all, cite historical references and dollar figures and adopt a faith-based view on business management by which you accept a single fundamental truth while ignoring every shred of concrete evidence that smashes it to pieces. Try to see the bigger picture here or come to terms with having to move to rural Mississippi.

Microsoft starts dropping Longhorn features

Microsoft has announced that several cool virtualization features will be dropped from what was promised for Longhorn release. Bink quotes a seemingly angry quote complaining about the lack of live migration, no hot-adding of resources, CPU core limitations, etc.

I’m sure there are many that will be very disappointed about this move.

I am not one of them.

Even though my business is based on the Microsoft virtualization platform (not Vmware) from a customer and partner scenario I am not looking forward to Longhorn’s virtualization feature set. That is not what I find exciting about the new server.

What I am particularly excited about is the new IIS 7 modular configuration and management, the new Longhorn Core Server free of the usual junk. Given the past year or so, I’d just like a reliable platform that Longhorn promises and they can release all the “cool” features when they feel they are ready.

First BIG loss for Exchange, HUGE loss for Microsoft

It sucks to lose, but when you lose big it makes you scratch your head about your approach.

May 6, 2007: Biggest Exchange loss in over 10 years. (at least in Vladville)

Comcast chose Zimbra to power it’s SmartZone portal. This is certainly a big loss for Microsoft Exchange but they will be OK, they are still in many ways untouchable by Zimbra when it comes to collaboration and the feature set.

Microsoft is the huge loser here. Conceptually. Ignore for the moment the financial loss here. Ignore even the boost this will give to Zimbra competitively, financially, marketing-wise, etc. Ignore the fact that none of these systems will run Windows, effectively wiping out a huge server deployment.

Ignore all those little details that hardly impact Microsoft.

Focus instead on the huge Las Vegas-style billboard this puts up to Microsoft: “Unbundle.”

Make no mistake, Microsoft didn’t lose this one on the cost – I’m sure they would have haggled it in. They didn’t lose this one on technology or feature set. They didn’t lose this one on the server stability and reliability.

They lost this one because, after years of alienating partners, Microsoft’s anti-competitive bundling strategy is starting to alienate it’s customers as well.

Comcast selected Bizanga, Cloudmark, Plaxo and Trend Micro. If you’ve ever seen my many presentations and tech dives on Microsoft Exchange 2007 you’re aware that there is very little acknowledgement of anything outside of Microsoft in that install or deployment. Microsoft Hosted Security, Microsoft Forefront, Microsoft Antigen, Microsoft LCS, Microsoft UM, Microsoft, Microsoft, Microsoft.

Today’s head-scratcher? Sometimes 12 million users customers want flexibility. Flexibility that Microsoft fails to demonstrate by forcing offering Microsoft-only solutions.

Dear Microsoft, you still need your partners. It might be a good time to start being nicer to us. 

Is that an SBSC logo in your window?

Eric writes about how SBSC partners will be recognized for their SBSC certification at a location basis instead of the organization as a whole. This is particularly useful for us bigger folks with multiple points of presence because we now have the ability to showcase our expertise in each location we have an SBSC qualified individual. (multiple locations = multiple listings = mo leads = mo money) 

In less than two years that SBSC has been around it has really matured into a seriously relevant Microsoft program. For a list of additional changes please check out the blog post over at Small Business Community Blog.

Wishlist: Bring to USA some of the recertification requirements that UK has. There are too many people in the program already that barely passed 70–282 and with the bootcamp and paper-SBSC conferences popping up it could seriously damage the credibility of the program if a person that is 70% comfortable with SBS/Vista is allowed to continue advertising themselves as a certified entity years after they have been certified. While I’m sure things are wide open to grow awareness, participation and membership in SBSC I hope Microsoft soon considers measures that control the quality of the program’s members.

Get a free Exchange 2007 demo account

Want to try out Exchange 2007 for free but don't want to install it or play sysadmin? Well, I have good news, Microsoft and Unisys have teamed up to offer a free trial account. Fill out a form with three fields and you're in.

Brings a serious question to mind to a lot of people – Is Microsoft going to go into hosting? Absolutely, they already do so with Office Live and as more people ditch their impossible-to-budget IT departments for outsourced hosted services Microsoft will really have no alternative but to go that route.

So check out Exchange 2007, bet you’ll love it, everyone does. And when you’re done with the demo, I know someone that can hook you up for $10 a month

Vladville volcano NOT related to 933493

Well, got my tale between my legs. The little eruption here regarding the crashed Outlook at 5 hours of downtime were not related to Outlook performance fix kb933493. I am not sure if I’m allowed to comment on what the actual issue is.

So allow me to extend my apology to the Outlook team and thanks to Paul Fitzgerald and Terry Mahaffey. They both, along with a lead dev, test engineer and support engineer ran to my rescue this morning and had an answer by the late afternoon. Terry was able to locate my Crash Report, I submitted the first one which took about 8 minutes to upload.

I’ve gotten a handful of reports of the exact same scenario happening to you. If you are experiencing it, and you did report a dump, and you have the bucket # from event 1001 send it my way and I’ll submit it to them as well. As for the blog post being pulled, I did so as soon as they contacted me and actually offered to help. Given the track record of my blog and business relationship with Microsoft, I see no reason to fault them when they are at fault, as my partners do to me at www.ownwebnow.com/forums. The software is designed to work, you pay for it to work, and you feel the heat whenever you don’t live up to your promise. But we all make mistakes and when people are actually trying they don’t deserve to be beaten in public as well. Yes my Outlook blew up, yes I could have been down for hours if that was my only PC, yes my cofidence is shaken… but these guys jumped all over this issue and got to the bottom of it the same day which is what I have been looking for all along. In the time when Microsoft is firming committment to release software more rapidly we as partners and customers (no, my copy wasn’t free) need to be assured that Microsoft has a committment to supporting their technology. Today went a loooong way towards that, at least for me. 

On Microsoft

Just wanted to clear the air a little because I got an email from a Microsoft PM today that said, paraphrasing “We want to keep you as an MVP and a fan of the product”. So for him and all the other Microsoft people who seem to have their heads chopped off on this blog on the daily basis, here was my response:

I'm still a HUGE fan. It's what I run on my desktops, laptops, phones, game console. The only things in house not running Microsoft are the router and the file server. So there is no love lost here.

Business-wise, Microsoft is killing us. The bigger we get, the more we spend on process and change control of Microsoft products yet our SLA and satisfaction ratings are in the toilet because we have run out of excuses to explain to people why we can't get by one week without a problem. Not just that, but with every issue there is a "cascade fault effect" by which we are blamed for every remotely related issue to the problem and have to prove it's not our fault by fixing it. Then just when everything is back in order we get blindsided again.

OWN is in a very interesting edge of the server-based services. Because everyone and everything is remote we don’t have the benefit of setting our own risk tollerance that Susan talks about all the time. Our risk is the day of, or in some cases like the latest DNS warning, weeks before Microsoft produces a hotfix/patch. We patch immediately because we are a large enough target, with a large enough pipe and buffet-style storage that make us a target for anyone field testing their latest exploit. You can’t set your own risk level by blackholing /21 sized subnets access to port 80, it’s a different scope of service.

My biggest beef with Microsoft on the business side is the lack of business owner level type of threat assessment that is as readily available as their marketing. When a business owner is down due to a Microsoft patch, hotfix, etc I need Microsoft to corroborate my story and act like my partner. I need my customers to be able to see the problem, confirm with Microsoft, and let me go about fixing it without having to sit in with the management of each affected company and try to explain technical jargon to a customer without a way to back it all up through doing my own forensics, technet articles, newsgroup posts, etc.

But since I know that Microsoft’s upper management reads my blog and knows just how hardheaded I am… How would you like it if your partners got together and created a public site to collect and share issues related to latest hotfixes and patches in the open so that customers themselves can see the the wide death-toll counts?

Required Reading: Microsoft Security Explained

This is not a joke, not a Geek Squad employee recording their customers in the shower, not a deathbed confession of who killed JFK. This is real. This is the most eloquently put illustration of Microsofts incompetence / ignorance. I wish I could write like this but unfortunately I’m the one paying for it so my points tend to become far more fiery.

http://hiltont.blogspot.com/2007/04/microsoft-patch-releases.html

Print that page, forward it to your staff, forward it to your clients and forward it to your IT peers. This blog post picks apart Microsoft’s lack of commitment to releasing solid patches and I think you’ll all agree that we have put up with enough stuff this century, to the point that most of us have labs, overhead/overtime, infrastructure/WSUS and additional software… all to do the job that Microsoft should have done prior to their releases.

We either make light of this all and demand change or we shut off our patching and let the servers fall where they may.

You have 8 more months to get that XP box

Bink is reporting about the end of the road for OEM XP installations coming at the end of the year. That’s right, coming January 2008 you will no longer be able to purchase a brand new computer with Windows XP.

To most of us in the IT world that use Vista there is probably little compassion on this front. First, Vista rocks. Second, if you’re a business you can purchase Windows under volume licensing programs that allow for use of previous releases of the software. So who does this impact?

SOHO’s and small business that doesn’t subscribe to Volume Licensing because of the “double licensing charge”. SOHO is not getting Software Assurance. Small business that doesn’t have a predictable growth pattern will buy systems one at a time.

So where are these segments going to? It pains me to say, but we’re seeing more and more Apple systems out there used in business. What does this mean for Microsoft? Well, they could again try to lower the bar on piracy so more people would install the useful higher-end versions of Vista… but I doubt that will happen. Piracy has been marginalized in business due to two factors: security and fairness. First, you can no longer trust that the image you get from a warez site (new kids read: bittorrent) is not loaded with rootkits, etc. Second, consumers are less likely to commit a criminal act of theft if they can get a reasonable alternative at a reasonable price. For example, Mac OS X is around $100 and upgrades for less than that. Ubuntu Linux is free. Both present a compelling alternative to a startup that is not bound to Microsoft’s platform.

Why am I telling you all this? Well, this market development is causing Own Web Now to start supporting these alternative platforms because they are showing up at our clients sites. Customer is always right, eh?

Daily Humor: iPhone for Windows Mobile

I-phone-emulator-for-windows-mobile-1

This cracked me up. Someone wrote an iPhone emulator for Windows Mobile. Would I have died to be in on that discussion: “Here we have an awesome portable media appliance, cell phone, remote management platform…. how do we dumb down the crap out of it and turn it into a pre-K toy? Oh, I know, how about an iPhone emulator?”

Have to admit, the product that the developer of this software has (Pocket Programming Language) seems to be a very impressive little IDE for form creation and management for Pocket PC applications. We’re working on a Shockey Monkey mobile agent right now and something like this would really have come useful about a month or so ago and it’s really gonna be useful going forward. Mobile forms management in Visual Studio….